See also: RNA editing and alternative splicing: the importance of co-transcriptional coordination
Apparently, the theorists did not think the facts about energy-dependent RNA editing and alternative splicings of pre-mRNA would be detailed.
But see for comparison: James Kohl reviews: The Emperor of Scent: A Story of Perfume, Obsession and the Last Mystery of the Senses
More than a century ago, in 1900, Max Planck, one of the greatest physicists of all time, announced his revolutionary new scientific theory of an energy constant in quantum mechanics. Eighteen years later he was awarded a Nobel Prize.
As Luca Turin waits for his rewards/award, he and others may benefit from knowing more about Planck’s attitude: “…a new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it.”
See also the review by Avery Gilbert: a human pheromone-denier (per Leslie Vosshall). The link opens the .pdf
Gilbert, A.N. 2003. The emperor’s new theory. Review of “The emperor of scent: A story of perfume, obsession, and the last mystery of the senses”, by Chandler Burr. Nature Neuroscience 6:335.
Against this reality, Emperor of Scent represents a triumphalist account of an unproven alternate theory. In ancient Rome, the honor of a triumph was reserved for an emperor who achieved a glorious victory. Should Turin’s conjecture prove correct, he will of course deserve one. But until then, this appears to be a case of premature adulation.
Gilbert’s claims about premature adulation can be compared to the claims of other pseudoscientists. Serious scientists have not been afraid to link claims of adulation from the creation of energy to the creation of all biodiversity via the physiology of reproduction. The serious scientists linked Turin’s theory to every aspect of energy-dependent biophysically constrained biodiversity via the feedback loops that link the sense of smell from the pheromone-controlled physiology of reproduction to viral latency.
See: Feedback loops link odor and pheromone signaling with reproduction
Even those who might not have believed that Luca Turin correctly represented energy-dependent top-down causation in the context of links from quantum physics to chemistry and all biologically-based diversity had little doubt that food odors and pheromones are the obvious link from olfaction to survival of all species.
The next reformation: 500 years too late? (3)